Are you looking to sell part of your home’s garden for development? Take note and proceed with caution!
The First Tier Tribunal case of Nunn v HMRC (March 2024) considers the availability of Principal Private Residence (PPR) relief from Capital Gains Tax and highlights a number of important considerations.
Nunn v HMRC (March 2024)
In this case, Mr Nunn sold off part of his garden to a developer to build two houses, for an agreed fixed price of £295,000. Heads of Terms were agreed, planning was granted, but for various reasons there was a delay to the exchange of contracts. Due to good weather conditions, the developer was keen to make progress on the works. They sent a letter to Mr Nunn saying that they had agreed to a contract to start work before exchange of contracts and asked Mr Nunn to sign and return the letter, which he duly did.
Mr Nunn claimed PPR relief on the disposal of the garden land, which fell within the “permitted area” (for the purposes of TCGA 1992). HMRC disallowed this on the basis that when the exchange of contracts for sale took place, the garden land was no longer part of his residence, due to the commencement of the works.
The First Tier Tribunal found in favour of Mr Nunn on the basis that he had made a deemed disposal of the property on the date he signed the letter referred to above. It was considered that it had triggered “an appropriation to trading stock” on that day. In other words, the property was no longer a part of his residence and became “stock” or “trade” when he signed the letter, which he then proceeded to sell.
Capital Gains Tax and Principal Private Residence Relief
Whilst this decision is not binding authority, it does provide some useful commentary on the likelihood of a successful PPR claim on the sale of a garden. The Tribunal set out three scenarios:
- The land retains its character as forming part of the garden to the residence up to the point of sale. PPR will likely be available;
- There is an arrangement in place with a professional developer to start work prior to exchange of contracts, where “development activities are carried out and profits shared”. In such a case there may well be a “deemed disposal to trading stock” when the development started. At that point PPR relief would be available (as long as the other PPR requirements are met); and
- A circumstance between the first two scenarios. That is to say, the land has not retained its character as a garden, but the extent of the development activity is not enough to constitute a deemed disposal to qualify as an appropriation to trading stock.
The Tribunal considered the facts of this case fell within the second scenario. This appears to be a rather generous approach from the Tribunal, given that the facts showed there was no sharing of profits. Therefore, it would not be surprising if this decision is subject to appeal by HMRC.
Practically, it would be prudent to err on the side of caution in similar situations. Don’t assume that a deemed disposal by way of appropriation to trading stock will be accepted by the Tribunal. It is best, therefore, postpone the commencement of works on the garden land until exchange of contracts has taken place.
For all your legal needs, contact Bond Adams on 01162858080 or lawyers@bondadams.com.
Contact us
Bond Adams Solicitors
Richmond House
94 London Road
LEICESTER
LE2 0QS
0116 285 8080
lawyers@bondadams.com
Follow Bond Adams on Facebook to stay up to date with all the latest news, guides and tips.


Comments are closed.